Understanding the International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) and How it Compares to the O1 Visa

The O-1 Visa is a non-immigrant visa in the United States designed for individuals who possess extraordinary ability in their field. It is often used by professionals in industries such as sciences, arts, business, education, and athletics. The visa is also a popular option for international entrepreneurs who have demonstrated exceptional achievements and want to enter the U.S. to continue their work or expand their ventures.

To qualify for the O-1 Visa, the applicant must provide evidence of national or international recognition in their area of expertise. This can include awards, published work, media coverage, significant contributions to their field, or serving in a key role at a prestigious organization. Specifically for entrepreneurs, being a founder of a high-growth startup or receiving considerable media attention and investment for their business could help demonstrate "extraordinary ability."

The O-1 Visa offers several advantages:

• It can be initially granted for up to three years and extended indefinitely in one-year increments.
• There is no limit to the number of O-1 Visas issued each year, unlike some other U.S. work visas.
• Applicants can bring their family members (spouse and children) to the U.S. under O-3 status, and they may also bring key employees under different visa categories.

However, the O-1 Visa requires substantial proof of extraordinary ability, making the application process more complex and rigorous. It is well-suited for entrepreneurs who have already gained significant recognition and success in their industry.

While the O-1 Visa provides a strong option for talented entrepreneurs, it may not be suitable for everyone, particularly early-stage startup founders who lack the high level of prestige or recognition required for this visa.

While both the International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) and the O-1 Visa provide opportunities for foreign entrepreneurs to live and work in the U.S., they cater to different types of individuals and offer distinct benefits. Here's a comparison of the two options to help you understand which might be more suitable based on your circumstances.

‍1. Eligibility Criteria

• ‍IER: The International Entrepreneur Rule is aimed at startup founders who may not yet have achieved significant international recognition but can demonstrate potential through their business ventures. To qualify, an entrepreneur must hold at least a 10% ownership stake in a U.S.-based startup, have an active role in the company, and show that the startup has received substantial U.S. investment (typically $250,000 or more) or government grants.

‍

• O-1 Visa: The O-1 Visa, on the other hand, is designed for individuals with extraordinary ability in fields such as business, sciences, or the arts. It requires that the applicant has achieved national or international acclaim, demonstrated through awards, media recognition, contributions to their field, or leadership roles in prestigious organizations. This visa is more focused on the individual’s achievements rather than the potential of a startup.

‍2. Recognition Level

• IER: The IER is accessible for entrepreneurs who might still be in the early or growth stages of their business and haven't necessarily gained widespread industry acclaim. The emphasis is on the startup’s potential to contribute to the U.S. economy through job creation and innovation.
• O-1 Visa: The O-1 Visa is for entrepreneurs who are already well-established in their field, having reached a high level of success and recognition. Applicants for the O-1 Visa need to prove their extraordinary achievements and demonstrate how their entry into the U.S. would continue to benefit their sector.

‍3. Duration of Stay

• IER: Entrepreneurs under the IER can stay in the U.S. for an initial period of 30 months (2.5 years), with the possibility of an additional 30-month extension. This gives startup founders time to scale their businesses and generate economic impact in the U.S. However, the IER is a temporary stay and doesn’t provide a direct pathway to permanent residence.

‍

• O-1 Visa: The O-1 Visa allows an initial stay of up to three years, with the option to extend the visa in one-year increments. There is no limit to the number of extensions, which makes it a more flexible option for long-term residency, especially if the individual continues to maintain their extraordinary status.

‍4. Path to Permanent Residency

• IER: The IER is a parole status and doesn’t lead directly to permanent residency (a green card). Entrepreneurs would need to explore other immigration pathways, such as employment-based visas, if they wish to stay in the U.S. permanently.

‍

• O-1 Visa: The O-1 Visa can be used as a stepping stone toward permanent residency. O-1 holders can often transition to a green card under the EB-1 visa category, which is for individuals of extraordinary ability, offering a direct path to permanent residency.

‍5. Application Process and Requirements

• IER: The application process for the IER is generally more straightforward for startup founders. It requires proof of startup investment and business potential rather than personal accomplishments. However, as it is not a formal visa, it operates under a discretionary parole process.

‍

• O-1 Visa: The O-1 Visa application process is more demanding and involves gathering substantial documentation to prove the applicant’s extraordinary ability. This includes providing evidence of awards, published work, media recognition, and letters from experts in the field. The process can be more rigorous due to the high standards of proof required.

‍6. Suitability for Entrepreneurs

• IER: The IER is more suitable for early-stage entrepreneurs and startup founders who are looking for an entry point into the U.S. market and need time to build their businesses. It focuses on the potential of the business rather than the individual’s personal achievements.
• O-1 Visa: The O-1 Visa is ideal for entrepreneurs who have already gained significant recognition and are looking to expand their influence in the U.S. market. It works best for founders who are well-established in their field and have a proven track record of success.

The International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) is geared towards startup founders with promising ventures and focuses on economic impact through business growth. It is more accessible for those at earlier stages of their entrepreneurial journey. The O-1 Visa, on the other hand, is best suited for highly accomplished entrepreneurs who have already achieved substantial industry recognition.

‍

Choosing between the International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) and the O-1 Visa depends on your personal achievements, the stage of your business, and your long-term goals for living and working in the United States. Here's a guide to help you decide:

‍1. Are You an Established Entrepreneur with Global Recognition?

If you are an entrepreneur who has already achieved international acclaim or significant recognition in your industry, the O-1 Visa may be a better fit for you. The O-1 Visa is specifically tailored for individuals with extraordinary ability in their field. Entrepreneurs with notable awards, significant media attention, or leadership roles in prestigious companies would likely meet the criteria for the O-1 Visa.

‍2. Are You in the Early Stages of Building a High-Potential Startup?

If your business is at an early stage or in a growth phase but hasn’t yet reached international acclaim, the IER could be the ideal choice. The IER is designed for international entrepreneurs who have a substantial ownership stake in a U.S.-based startup and have secured significant investment or funding from U.S. investors. This rule focuses more on the potential of your business rather than your individual achievements, making it a more accessible option for early-stage entrepreneurs.

‍3. Do You Plan to Stay in the U.S. Long-Term?

If your goal is to transition to permanent residency in the U.S., the O-1 Visa might offer a better pathway. O-1 Visa holders can often transition to a green card under the EB-1 visa category, which is aimed at individuals with extraordinary ability. The IER, on the other hand, is a temporary measure that does not directly lead to permanent residency. If long-term residency is important to you, the O-1 Visa provides a clearer route to achieving this goal.

‍4. Do You Have Access to U.S. Investment?

Both the IER and O-1 Visa have different focuses when it comes to investment. Under the IER, your startup must demonstrate potential by securing substantial U.S. investment (typically $250,000 or more from qualified investors). If you have access to such funding and believe in your business's future in the U.S., the IER might be the right fit.

The O-1 Visa doesn’t require proof of startup funding but instead focuses on your personal accomplishments. If your strength lies in your individual track record, the O-1 Visa may be a better option, especially if you are not dependent on investment criteria.

‍5. Is Flexibility Important to You?

If you need flexibility in terms of staying in the U.S. for the long term, the O-1 Visa provides more room for indefinite extensions, as long as you continue to meet the visa requirements. In contrast, the IER is limited to an initial 30 months, with a possibility of one extension for another 30 months. After that, you'll need to explore other visa options or immigration pathways.

Ultimately, the International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) is ideal for early-stage startup founders with a vision to grow their business in the U.S., but who may not yet have achieved significant international recognition. It offers an accessible entry point for startups, especially those with strong U.S. investment backing.

The O-1 Visa, however, is best suited for accomplished entrepreneurs who have already established themselves as leaders in their field. If you have a proven track record and desire a long-term presence in the U.S. with the possibility of transitioning to permanent residency, the O-1 Visa could be the right choice.

‍

When applying for the International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) or the O-1 Visa, each route has specific steps that need to be followed. Here's an overview of the key steps involved in both processes:

‍1. International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) Application Process

The IER operates under a discretionary parole process, which allows entrepreneurs to enter the U.S. based on their startup’s potential rather than their personal recognition. Below are the steps involved:

1. Eligibility Check: Ensure that you meet the basic eligibility requirements:some text
   • You must own at least 10% of a U.S.-based startup.
   • You must play an active role in the operations of the company.
   • Your startup must have received at least $250,000 in investment from qualified U.S. investors or $100,000 in government grants.

‍

2. Prepare Evidence of Startup Potential: Gather documents to prove that your startup has the potential to grow and create jobs in the U.S. This may include:some text
   • Investment agreements
   • Letters from investors or government agencies
   • Business plans showing projected growth and employment
   • Documentation of the startup's innovation and its impact on the market

    3. Complete Form I-941: File Form I-941 (Application for Entrepreneur Parole) with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). This form includes details about your startup, your role, and your eligibility for parole.

‍

      4. Submit Supporting Documents: Along with the form, you’ll need to submit the supporting documentation that shows your startup’s eligibility, such as investment proof, business records, and your role in the company.

‍

       5. Pay the Filing Fee: Pay the required fee (currently $1,200), which must be submitted along with the application.

‍

       6. Await USCIS Decision: Once your application is submitted, USCIS will review your case. If approved, you will be granted parole status for 30 months, which allows you to enter and work in the U.S.

‍

      7. Extension of Parole: If your startup continues to show growth and receives additional funding, you can apply for an extension for another 30 months by providing updated evidence.

‍

‍

2. O-1 Visa Application Process

The O-1 Visa requires applicants to demonstrate extraordinary ability and recognition in their field. Below are the key steps:

1. Determine Your Eligibility: Confirm that you meet the qualifications for the O-1 Visa by demonstrating extraordinary ability in your field. This can be achieved by providing evidence such as:some text
   • Awards or accolades in your industry
   • Media coverage or publications featuring your work
   • Leadership roles at distinguished organizations
   • Letters from experts vouching for your abilities

‍

2. Consult with a Sponsor: Unlike the IER, the O-1 Visa requires a U.S.-based sponsor or agent to file the petition on your behalf. The sponsor could be an employer, an agent, or even your own startup if it is a legal entity established in the U.S.

‍

3. File Form I-129: Your sponsor will file Form I-129 (Petition for Nonimmigrant Worker) with USCIS. This form must include a detailed description of your extraordinary abilities and achievements, as well as the proposed work you will be doing in the U.S.

‍

        4. Submit Evidence of Extraordinary Ability: Along with Form I-129, submit evidence that proves you meet the O-1 criteria. This evidence can include:some text

1. Awards or prizes received
2. Published work about you or your achievements
3. Letters from experts in your field
4. Contracts or proof of business accomplishments (for entrepreneurs)

‍

     5. Pay Filing Fee: The required filing fee (currently $460) must be paid at the time of submission.

‍

     6. Wait for USCIS Approval: USCIS will review your petition and supporting evidence. If approved, you will be issued an O-1 Visa that allows you to work in the U.S. for up to three years, with the possibility of extending the visa in one-year increments.

‍

      7. Visa Issuance: After approval by USCIS, you will need to attend a visa interview at the U.S. embassy or consulate in your country to finalize the visa issuance.

‍

‍

Challenges and Opportunities

‍

Both the International Entrepreneur Rule (IER) and the O-1 Visa offer unique opportunities for international entrepreneurs looking to establish or expand their businesses in the U.S., but each comes with its own set of challenges.

Challenges:

• The IER has strict funding requirements, making it difficult for startups that haven't secured substantial U.S. investment.
• The O-1 Visa demands a high level of personal achievement and recognition, which may not be feasible for entrepreneurs in the early stages of their careers.
• Both options are temporary, with the IER offering limited extensions and no direct path to permanent residency, while the O-1 Visa requires continuous proof of extraordinary ability for renewal.

Opportunities:

• The IER provides an entryway for early-stage entrepreneurs, allowing them to build and grow their startups in a dynamic market.
• The O-1 Visa offers a pathway for highly accomplished entrepreneurs to work and live in the U.S., with the potential to transition to a green card.
• Both visas allow entrepreneurs to access the U.S. market, leverage U.S. investment, and take advantage of a thriving entrepreneurial ecosystem.

Understanding these challenges and opportunities can help you make an informed decision about which visa is the best fit for your business journey in the U.S.

‍

How Tech Nomads can help 

‍

Do you find it hard to showcase and structure your achievements for the USA O-1 Visa application? Or are you uncertain about which experiences USCIs finds most relevant? Tech Nomads has you covered. 

‍

Tech Nomads is a global mobility platform that provides services for international relocation. Established in 2018, Tech Nomads has a track record of successfully relocating talents and teams. Our expertise in adapting to regulatory changes ensures our clients’ satisfaction and success.

To explore your relocation options, you may:

‍

• Assess your chance with a Tech Nomads Global Mobility Expert
• Read guides and articles on the Tech Nomads website

‍

Subscribe to our social media platforms to stay up-to-date on global mobility news and opportunities:

• LinkedIn
• Facebook
• Instagram
• Telegram
• X

‍

‍

‍